| 1972 | | The Bells of Bruges |
| 1973 | | The Wizard of Oz |
| 1974 | | Listen to the Wind |
| 1975 | | A Christmas Carol / I'll Get My Man |
| 1976 | | Topsy Turvey Castle / Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat |
| 1977 | | The Love Birds / The Big Band Show |
| 1978 | | Animal Capers / The Wizard of Oz |
| 1979 | | West Side Story / Captain and His Floating Zoo |
| 1980 | | The Best of Protea / Listen to the Wind |
| 1981 | | Peter Pan / Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs |
| 1982 | | Alice in Wonderland / Babes in Arms / Carols Come to Life |
| 1983 | | Protea Playtime '83 / A Christmas Carol |
| 1984 | | Half a Sixpence / The Wizard of Oz |
| 1985 | | Seven Brides for Seven Brothers / Mini Pops |
| 1986 | | Can Can / Tales of Beatrix Potter |
| 1987 | | Bugsy Malone / Prism |
| 1988 | | The Adventures of Tom Sawyer / Finians Rainbow |
| 1989 | | The Jungle Book / Bye, Bye Blue Jeans |
| 1990 | | Brigadoon / Pinocchio |
| 1991 | | Dracula Spectacula / Mary Poppins |
| 1992 | | Rockafella / Water Babies |
| 1993 | | Annie Get Your Gun / Peter Pan |
| 1994 | | A Funny Thing Happened On the way to the Forum / Three and a Half Musketeers |
| 1995 | | West Side Story |
| 1996 | | Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat |
| 1997 | | Leader of the Pack / Robin Hood |
| 1998 | | Pinocchio / Sweeney Todd |
| 1999 | | Cindy Ella |
| 2000 | | Mary Poppins |
| 2001 | | God Spell |
| 2002 | | West Side Story / Comedy Tonight / Be Our Guest |
| 2003 | | The Magic Faraway Tree / The Boyfriend / Wish Upon A Star |
| 2004 | | Broadway Hits The Highveld / Jesus Christ Superstar |
| 2005 | | Oliver / OnStage |
| 2006 | | Alice in Wonderland / A Funny Thing Happened On The Way To The Forum |
| 2007 | | Peter Pan / Darling Mr. London |
| 2008 | | Pinocchio / Tom, Dick & Harry |
| 2009 | | The Wizard of Oz / Scrooge |
| 2010 | | The Jungle Book / Key For Two |
| 2011 | | No Room For Love / Mary Poppins |
| 2012 | | Loves a Luxury |
